Guilloche pendant OR vintage gold Diamond

[Penamonvie]

Hi guys, here is my dilemma. Just received the guilloche pendant. But the Diamond one is 4K more. Or should I keep the guilloche and in couple months get a 10 motif which is just 1k more than the Diamond single pendant. If I do decide to get a 10 motif, which one?

 

[rat_stack]

Hi guys, here is my dilemma. Just received the guilloche pendant. But the Diamond one is 4K more. Or should I keep the guilloche and in couple months get a 10 motif which is just 1k more than the Diamond single pendant. If I do decide to get a 10 motif, which one? View attachment 5299405

I would keep the guilloche. I'm not impressed by VCA pave pieces. Guilloche looks shinier and more beautiful IMO.

 

[880]

They’re different pieces, but the one you bought is the simplest and smallest of all of them. If you are truly unsure, take a credit or return this one and wait until you fall in love with a specific piece, then buy that one. When I buy something, I strive to love it so much, there is no need to second guess

 

[Obsessed_girl]

Single pendent and 10 motif pendent is a must. Keep the guilloche pendent , and save for stone 10 motif

 

[Runisaa]

Bumping to see new perspectives or if opinion has changed. Which would you go with: Guilloche vs diamond vintage single motif pendant?

 

[Axelle838]

Bumping to see new perspectives or if opinion has changed. Which would you go with: Guilloche vs diamond vintage single motif pendant?

Personally I'd stick with the guilloche, I'm not a huge fan of the diamond motif.

 

[marbella8]

I personally don’t like the single-motif Guilloche. It’s too much, too bright, too yellow, and too mirrory, FOR ME. To disrespect to those that wear it and look fabulous. At the same time, I think the single-motif pave is way overpriced.

 

[glitzgal97]

I have both pendants and love them both, sorry I’m no help! That said, two of my friends also bought the guilloche pendant and we all love it so maybe stick with guilloche?

 

[DS2006]

I favor the diamond pendant, personally. I have it in white gold.

 

[Runisaa]

I have both pendants and love them both, sorry I’m no help! That said, two of my friends also bought the guilloche pendant and we all love it so maybe stick with guilloche?

Would love to hear your thoughts on the difference between them? Which shines brighter? Which looks dressier? Which is lower maintenance? When would you wear diamond vs guilloche? Thanks!

 

[marbella8]

I personally don’t like the single-motif Guilloche. It’s too much, too bright, too yellow, and too mirrory, FOR ME. To (I meant NO disrespect, not TO) disrespect to those that wear it and look fabulous. At the same time, I think the single-motif pave is way overpriced.

 

[AnaBeavTheOG]

Would love to hear your thoughts on the difference between them? Which shines brighter? Which looks dressier? Which is lower maintenance? When would you wear diamond vs guilloche? Thanks!

The guilloche is plenty bright enough that it's not worth the extra cost for pave for me. But there is something about the contrast of YG and colorless diamonds that seems to give it more visual interest.

In terms of maintenance, I haven't been worrying about scratches or anything. Granted I've only had my guilloche for a few months. But since I don't stack my pendants, there's very little chance of it getting damaged. I figure, if I do something to it to mangle the guilloche, then pave isn't going to fare much better in that case.

 

[Runisaa]

The guilloche is plenty bright enough that it's not worth the extra cost for pave for me. But there is something about the contrast of YG and colorless diamonds that seems to give it more visual interest.

In terms of maintenance, I haven't been worrying about scratches or anything. Granted I've only had my guilloche for a few months. But since I don't stack my pendants, there's very little chance of it getting damaged. I figure, if I do something to it to mangle the guilloche, then pave isn't going to fare much better in that case.

Super helpful- thanks !

 

[eternallove4bag]

Bumping to see new perspectives or if opinion has changed. Which would you go with: Guilloche vs diamond vintage single motif pendant?

I prefer the VA pave pendant more. Maybe I am biased because I own it in RG and wear it to death!

 

[WingNut]

I prefer the VA pave pendant more. Maybe I am biased because I own it in RG and wear it to death!

Same. Mine's in YG and I wear it a ton. For some reason I haven't warmed up to the Guilloche as much...