Gucci Dionysus, LV Twist, YSL Kate or something else? Help!

[inverved]

Hi everyone!

While I spent a lot of this year decluttering and selling bags, SLG's, etc, I now realise that I have a slight gap in my bag collection. I am looking for a black bag with silver hardware that is versatile... something that can take me from day to night. I already have an LV Alma BB in Epi Noir and Chanel Timeless CC flap in black caviar with silver hardware, otherwise the rest of my designer bags are in gold hardware. Seeing as most of them are Hermes and Chanel, I thought I would go for something that is different, not as expensive but still on the classic side.

So far, I'm looking at these...

Gucci Dionysus Mini:



LV Twist Belt Wallet:


YSL Small Kate:


Would you go for one of these or something else I may have not considered? Opinions are greatly appreciated, especially if you own any of them. Thanks!

 

[cncm]

I think the Gucci is the most stunning of these three options - I may be biased of course since I own it in the small size in the monogram canvas. Mine is a little heavy but I think in the mini size you shouldn't have any weight issues.

 

[Venessa84]

I have both the Dionysus and the twist...I wear my twist a lot more so that one gets my vote.

 

[inverved]

Since I made this post, I've been reading about quality issues on different YSL bags in the forum, plus issues with crystals falling out of the Dionysus buckle.