Gucci boston bags -- yay or nay?

I'd say...Yay, because the Boston style bags has been very popular (profitable) for Gucci, they've just redesigned them every season. I almost got the third one. I've got an earlier style and I still love it!
 
I think there's something classic about this shape. I like them. I don't own one,though, and I wonder about how they actually carry. The look a bit shaped and bulky, for easy carrying. But I do like them.
 
Yay, I have the black velvet horsebit one that was in the F/W 05 ads. It's really easy to carry for a satchel, easy to get in and out of, and has metal feet on the bottom