gray or whiskey edith?

[mercer]

help help! what to do? I Finally got on the list for the NM whiskey edith. but....now Bergdorfs has emailed me saying i could get on the list for the gray.

which color should i go for? i tend to wear a lot of black....

 

[Kat]

If you wear a lot of black I'd go with the grey. I don't wear a lot of black and I'd still get the grey over the whiskey.

 

[ETenebris]

If it's between these two, would go for the whiskey. It's a nice contrast to the black. You don't want to look like you just stepped out of a black and white movie...it's a bit "blah." The whiskey has some red to it which is just beautiful. But if you are going "formal" the grey might be better. Rumor is there might be a black coming down the pipeline...

 

[nawth21]

I'd chose grey just because it'd go with my wardrobe better.

 

[kahk3000]

i'm not sure if i've seen the grey, but the whiskey is such a great color, so warm, i would go w/ that one.

 

[ETenebris]

i'm not sure if i've seen the grey, but the whiskey is such a great color, so warm, i would go w/ that one.

Here you go...

 

[kahk3000]

okay, wiskey definitely, i just think it fits the bag way better. I think that gray looks better on structure bags.

 

[ETenebris]

The whiskey just seems to "suit" the bag. It's funny...cars and bags seem to have one particular color that just really fits. I fell in love with the whiskey as soon as I saw the magazine ad. Had to have it. Just wish it would GET HERE already!

 

[Cristina]

I actually like the look of the grey Edith more than the whiskey. The whiskey is better for the paddy, in my opinion.

 

[abaglover]

I think whiskey looks better.

 

[addicted]

The pocket in the front just doesn't go with the grey (IMO). If it didn't have the pocket, different story.

I like the whisky better for this particular bag.

 

[mercer]

Here is a picture from the LVR site- I like the look of the gray in this picture. My worry about the whiskey is that someone mentioned it reminded them of those 1970's hippie bags and now i can't get that out of my head!

 

[SCL]

Whiskey seems like it would wear better across seasons. The light grey seems "spring" to me.

 

[BalenciagaLove]

My advice and sort of what I'm doing - Get on the list for both and then return whichever one you like less. Then you won't be second guessing yourself! And maybe you'll end up keeping both!

 

[Serenity Now]

I thought I wouldn't like the grey but after seeing these pics, it's not bad. Although, I'm not liking the black stitching on it - just looks awkward and funny.

Taking everything into account, I'd have to say I prefer the Whiskey.