I think it is a very sweet gift, but IMHO it is not a classic piece that she will be able to wear 10 years down the line. I have to agree with whoops on this, since after I got older, I started to like my watches to look like watches, and my bracelets to look like bracelets. I had a similar style watch from claires/target, or some place similar when I was in high school, and I really didn't miss it once it broke. I got a watch for my college graduation recently, and while I do like it, it is not a style I love, or would have picked out for myself. I would make sure to give your niece a gift receipt in case she wants to exchange the watch bracelet for something else in case she doesn't want to be impolite, and doesn't want to say anything/it isn't her style.