Goldenbleu Marilyn- Keep or not to keep?!

[Sassy]

I bought the Goldenbleu Marilyn in chocolate, and just received it. I like the shape and design, but the leather is very glossy and thin- almost pleather-ish. Does anyone else have a marilyn and feel the same way? Does it get better with age? Since I'm not crazy about the texture, I am inclined to return it but it was such a good deal!(50% off!) Should I just return it?
Pic of Marilyn:
http://www.goldenbleu.com/marilyn.html

What I may want to get instead if I return the marilyn :
http://store.shopbop.com/item.jsp?item=ANNAC1000212698&category=441

 

[pseub]

I like the second one much better.

 

[Kat]

If you are not crazy about the texture maybe it's a good idea to return it for something you will really love.

 

[USCgerl]

I like the second bag much better!

 

[helenNZ]

hmm, i actually like the first one... just because of the colour... something different!

 

[Serendipity]

I agree with the majority...return 1 and purchase 2.

 

[613]

Right now I am liking the first one more because of the metallic colour and the wrap-around strap. It's definitely more unique looking; but I think the second one is definitely more practical and will last a longer time. Also, the second one seems like it will match a larger variety of outfits.

 

[heartfelt]

i really like the second! i think the first has too much embellishment with the leather ties.

 

[SuLi]

I like the second one better. The Marilyn has an interesting look and color, but I think in the long run, you might like the second tote better.

 

[fashionfrenzy]

I say go for the second one--I am not crazy about the wrapping of the strap around the first one.

 

[Greenie]

Second one....BUT, that first one is kinda interesting looking, but if the leather isn't there...then you're probably better off with the second.

 

[B. Jara]

I bought the Goldenbleu Marilyn in chocolate, and just received it. I like the shape and design, but the leather is very glossy and thin- almost pleather-ish. Does anyone else have a marilyn and feel the same way? Does it get better with age? Since I'm not crazy about the texture, I am inclined to return it but it was such a good deal!(50% off!) Should I just return it?
Pic of Marilyn:
http://www.goldenbleu.com/marilyn.html

What I may want to get instead if I return the marilyn :
http://store.shopbop.com/item.jsp?item=ANNAC1000212698&category=441

It says temporarily unavailable....were you able to get it?

 

[Becca4277]

Love the second one, but I can see the appeal of the first one; very different and funky.

 

[vaneea]

i like the second one

 

[Maryam]

I actually think that the Marilyn is a gorgeous bag and I far prefer it to the second one.