Givenchy Small Antigona or Celine Mini Luggage?

[Savtse27]

Which would you buy if they were both at the same price point?

Givenchy Antigona Small in Purple - Smooth Leather

or

Celine Mini Luggage in Camel - Smooth Leather



I am deciding between the two at the moment. I've also attached some mod shot pictures of both that I found on google.

Thanks!

 

[Peridot_Paradise]

Antigona love the shape better and love the secure top zipper the celine mini luggage seems too trendy to me however i like that color better than the purple

 

[ZoobaAruba]

They're different prices, different sizes, different colors, not really comparable. I was trying to decide between the celine nano and the givenchy mini, I decided on the celine in the end.

I don't know if you've seen the givenchy irl, but the zipper is extremely bulky, that really put me off the bag. It's a disproportionate size to the bag and it kind of "snags" on the angles of the bag.

Also, the celine does have a zipper, so it's also secure, the open part isn't large enough for things to fall out.

The mini luggage is double the price of the mini givenchy though, so I would decide based on how much you're willing to spend.

 

[carlinha]

i love the purple givenchy!!!

 

[vanillasoul]

givenchy! for both the colour and design! i think celine luggage are on its way out...

 

[Shashaboo]

Tough decision! I vote for the mini luggage based on the color - its neutral so imo will be easier to wear.

 

[poohbag]

Antigona! I love my small Antigona! The zipper is a little bulky looking and not the smoothest zip as mentioned above but I think it gives the bag a slightly edgier look and I leave my bag unzipped most of the time. Over time it also becomes easier. To me, the bag has simple lines and is not too trendy looking, is light, and holds a good amount. The purple color may limit its versatility though.

I had both a nano and a micro and sold both. While they are gorgeous bags-love how they look, the excellent quality and ease of use, I felt they were beginning to look dated.

 

[j2my]

I personally like the Antigona because of the style and the shade of purple is so nice (purple is also my favourite colour - so I might be a bit biased. Haha). I also like the Celine too and the colour is nice but my concern is will it look dirty over time and will u have to clean it often? It will go with any outfit bc of the neutral tone but I would still go for the Givenchy purple 😜

 

[labellusting]

I have both bags, a red Celine mini and a navy medium Antigona, and my vote is the Celine.

While I like both, the Mini IMO is more versatile. I also think it's a classic bag. The shape is timeless and is easy to use. The opening on the Antigona is a little annoying, the Celinenis much easier.

I've had the Celine for 3 years and still get compliments to this day!

Good luck ☺️

 

[Belphoebe]

Givenchyyyyyyyy

Look how elegant and timeless it looks, how it dresses up or down. Makes the Celine look like a jack-o-lantern or a giant emoticon : [