Givenchy nightingale or YSL muse? Please help!

Nightingale or Muse? Please vote!

  • Givenchy nightingale- black medium size

  • YSL Muse I- black large size

Results are only viewable after voting.


Oct 20, 2009
Hi everyone, I'm debating between either a black medium Givenchy nightingale or black large YSL muse. I've tried on both and like them equally...I feel like they can hold similar amounts and are sort of similarly shaped too...I guess that's why it's so hard for me to decide between them! Which style do you think has the most longevity? Any opinions or advice? Thanks all!


in the untamed rabbit hole
May 25, 2006
New York City
obviously biased here given that I own several 'gales and no muse, but I say the nightingale b/c it's slightly less structured, can hold more and is more under the radar and therefore is not as dated as the muse. in addition, the strap is longer, and you can detach it if you just want to do the handheld thing. ive seen more reselling of muses than nightingales, so maybe that means that more people get more tired of their muse than their 'gales?
either way, both are nice bags.