Aww! Thank you for responding to me! Its just a gift from hubby and I wish I can keep both lol! I agree with you with the black being more statement. Have a great day!welcome! keep both, as the black one is a highly covetable bag, the embossing looks like the real thing and is very hard wearing. The cream is a great tone for year round wear and wardrobe matching. Looks great with winter whites to summer pastels to fall browns and navys. the black is also a bit more statement, gives all black outfits texture and slight sheen, while the cream is more casual. besides, every collection needs a dark and lighter color bag.
forgot to add that since they're diff sizes, more reason to keep both. add a twilly around the handle of the cream to change up the look too, and keep it clean.
Thank you for your opinion, I cant wait to see it in person next week! Im giving 60% yes already on the black.I think if you have to keep one, maybe the black- I think the size means it's more wearable whereas the mini you'll have to be selective when you can use it so cost per wear I think black will win.
Also the black leather will be more durable, Antigona bags scratch super easily so the cream you will have to baby because of smooth leather + colour!
But maybe later on if you love it, get it!