Given an opportunity, which one would u buy?

[rains]

I have been presented with an opportunity of either buying one of the 2 options only. Both bags are neutral colours. Which one would u pick and y?

1. A birkin or a HAC bag from a reseller which is a decade old, good condition.
2. A new bag which is a non-birkin/HAC/Kelly which is store fresh.

Would love to hear some serious opinions as I am thoroughly confused as to what do do, and I can pick only one.

TIA!!!

 

[Sinatra]

I have been presented with an opportunity of either buying one of the 2 options only. Both bags are neutral colours. Which one would u pick and y?

1. A birkin or a HAC bag from a reseller which is a decade old, good condition.
2. A new bag which is a non-birkin/HAC/Kelly which is store fresh.

Would love to hear some serious opinions as I am thoroughly confused as to what do do, and I can pick only one.

TIA!!!

Rains, It would be helpful to have more information about each of the two bags but given the information that you have provided, and assuming the birkin/HAC is in a condition which is acceptable to you, I would go with #1 !

 

[rains]

For option 1 , yes the bag is in great acceptable condition for a decade old.
For option 2, its a GM Evelyn.

Both are in neutral colors.

 

[Sinatra]

For option 1 , yes the bag is in great acceptable condition for a decade old.
For option 2, its a GM Evelyn.

Both are in neutral colors.

My vote remains #1

 

[rains]

Thanks for your opinion Sinatra. That really helps.

 

[Kealakoala15]

I would go with #1 too. I was faced with a similar decision (though it was a Garden Party for me) and I'm glad I chose the pre-loved route. When I unbuckle those straps, I still get a little too giddy

 

[Pinky_Loca]

i would go for choice 1...as long as i know for sure that its authentic...=)

 

[azoreh]

Choice #1 for me too! My 2nd H was a pre-loved birkin and I love her to bits! She's also my workhorse! My default bag!

 

[ouija board]

The two bags are so different in style, I guess it would depend on which you would use more often and most comfortably. For me, it would be the Birkin/HAC hands down, no hesitation.

 

[coleigh]

^^^I must agree.

 

[graycat5]

#1 for me too! No question.

 

[citrus]

Number one for sure

 

[hilwa]

# 1 for me.

 

[galex101404]

i'd go with choice #1, but you can't go wrong with either

 

[djmm]

I'd rather drive a 10 yr old Ferrari than a new Honda.