Gel Eyeliner, Bobbi Brown, MAC, Stila ?? help

[Nyria]

I need a new eyeliner - preferably a gel (I like cliniques but I want to try something else).

So which do you recommend more?

Bobbi Brown

MAC

STILA

Others?

 

[frostedcouture]

I like Bobbi brown and fluidlines. both are good, but i think bobbi brown is easier to use

 

[caarlyntryl]

Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner > MAC Fluidline, hands down.

Fluidline ran a lot for me. Actually, I hated that product. BB's liners, on the other hand, stayed put all day but were easy enough to take off at night with a little cleanser. Gorgeous, subtle colors, too!

 

[illinirdhd]

Love BB, but used Fluidline for the first time today and I like it too! Much prefer BB's liner brush to MAC's or Smashbox though.

 

[floodette]

BB hands down.

It's just almost every color I have turns black on me...

 

[ellacoach]

I have 1 from Bobbi Brown and 1 from Stila and I prefer the Bobbi Brown.

 

[SpoiledRotten22]

I have a MAC fluidline and a L'Oreal HIP gel liner and both work pretty well for me. I've heard good things about the BB as well and plan to try one of those.

 

[frostedcouture]

Stila smudge pots dry up fast.

 

[Nyria]

I didn't know L'Oreal had one too - I wonder if we have it in Canada yet???

I think I'll give the bobbi brown one a whirl - seeing as it sems to be the favourite here =)
Thanks everyone for your help !!!

 

[Lanier]

bobbi brown gel eyeliner > mac fluidline, hands down.

ita!

 

[Couture_Girl]

mac fluidline (:

 

[blonde79]

I prefer MAC fluidlines...I have 4 now. I do have one Clinique gel liner too, it's okay but not quite as nice as the MAC liners.

 

[itsnicole]

I've used both MAC & Bobbi Brown, and I prefer Bobbi Brown's. It's my favorite eyeliner.

 

[rbaby]

Bobbi Brown hands down. It's the only liner that goes on smooth and stays on all night for me.

 

[gelbergirl]

I recommend Laura Mercier. Try to get to the counter if you can and have them show it to you with the flat brush.
i also have the Bobbi Brown which I am still practicing with and really have to get the hang of it. I purchased it on an international flight with no make-up person to help me out. Any suggestions? I keep forgetting to go to the counter and I am not sure if they'll help me or not since I already have it.