KEEP BOTH THE NPs--they both look fantastic on you, congrats!
send those mary janes home! personally i don't think they're fabulous enough on you to keep--i think if you're going to spend that much on shoes, they should be damn hot! and the NPs are both gorgeous on you so... well you know what i think
If you can keep both, go for it! However, if you have to choose one, definitely keep the nudes. They are hard to come by and you will regret it if you return them. lol You will be amazed at how much you wear them. I own the NPs and haven't worn them yet b/c the strap is too big (need to have them cut down), but I wear all of my other nude patent CLs TONS.
Do you mind posting bigger photos of the fuchsia NPs? I was thinking of getting them, but I canceled my pre-order b/c I wasn't impressed w/ the stock photo. However, they look brighter IRL. Thanks!