Forest / Envy / Leaf / Emerald comprison pics..

littlerock

Love is Love is Love
Admin
O.G.
Apr 19, 2007
21,588
116
In the moment
This is a copied post from my Nikki reveal thread but I think it is useful enough to post a green comparison thread to discuss if necessary.

Emerald MAM posted by 3snuffles:


Leaf and Envy MAMs posted by Madges:


Forest MAM posted by Jennys315:


** I don't find that Envy to be that close to Forest AT ALL actually. Forest is so much darker and has more blue undertones. Envy has more yellow undertones similar to Emerald.
 

Bay

O.G.
Feb 7, 2007
6,381
2
I have to say I think forest is the most gorgeous out of these 3. However..I love all of them..Thanks for the pics!
 

littlerock

Love is Love is Love
Admin
O.G.
Apr 19, 2007
21,588
116
In the moment
^ Really?? Interesting because forest is my least favorite. Just goes to show that everyone has different tastes! I am sure that we will all have differing opinions :yes:
 

nawth21

Addicted!
O.G.
Feb 21, 2006
3,697
1
38
Twin Cities MN
^ Really?? Interesting because forest is my least favorite. Just goes to show that everyone has different tastes! I am sure that we will all have differing opinions :yes:
I love the forest as well, though i enjoy all the greens. I think it because it borders on a jewel tone green, it's that blue base I bet.
 

MAGJES

O.G.
Dec 13, 2008
23,232
27,433
North Carolina
After comparing these pics at length - I think that ENVY has to be my favorite - It's so close to Emerald but the pebbly leather makes it #1.


Oh no - now I want a Nikki in ENVY......
 

littlerock

Love is Love is Love
Admin
O.G.
Apr 19, 2007
21,588
116
In the moment
^ Envy is my favorite too :graucho:

Stick w/ your MAM... the grass is not always greener. I have the niki but contemplated trading for the MAM..LOL. I am just going to stick with the nikki though.
 

MrsShoeGal

O.G.
Sep 11, 2006
8,303
8
West Coast
I thik leaf is closest to emerald really leaf is in the darker emerald family. Wish I loved green bags I love them on everyone but me!!!
 

kdo

Let's Go Caps!
Nov 1, 2008
9,513
2
Thanks for putting together this comparison thread, LR. It is very helpful to see the greens together. My first love is Emerald but Envy is so yummy! I want!
 

gr8ful1

Member
Jul 15, 2008
2,052
2
I've never seen any of them IRL, but from those pics I like Forest the best. It never caught my eye before. Do you think that pic captures the true color? Because it definitely looks bluer and I've never noticed that before.

Thanks for putting the pics together, LR!
 
Sep 24, 2008
3,095
4,776
USA
I have an emerald mam and the leather is just divine. So smooshy and the brass.. and long tassels.... It was my HG RM. However I don't wear it too much because its summer and I feel it goes better with fall and winter.
 

lvdreamer

Enjoying Rain!
O.G.
Mar 27, 2007
12,352
112
Love this comparison thread. I love green bags generally, but forest is #1 in my heart (Love my Forest Nikki), but the Envy is gorgeous too.
 

littlerock

Love is Love is Love
Admin
O.G.
Apr 19, 2007
21,588
116
In the moment
I thik leaf is closest to emerald really leaf is in the darker emerald family. Wish I loved green bags I love them on everyone but me!!!
Leaf is actually quite lighter than Emerald, IMO. I have a Leaf Nikki, an Envy Nikki and an Emerald K&M and without a doubt, when I put them all next to each other, Envy & Emerald are closest. This is just my opinion of course.:biggrin: