EMNH, I didn't see LZ's pics (which are always superior) but in person Rodeo is pretty matte. Gorgeous texture and scent, too! I use a Bearn (old, ungussetted version) and small Azap. I like the Bearn because it's sleek but the hardware can be bothersome as mine has tarnished a bit. I prefer the smaller Azap since I don't carry too many cards. It also has a cute change comparment (lined in goat!)