This is my first "real" bag purchase, outside of a Coach I bought last year on eBay. I have an inherited 1990s saddle bag Dooney, but never use it-- it's a bit small and heavy. I'm looking at a few bags, and just can't decide. They're all QVC Easy Pay. I probably should try to find a sale, but.. I didn't see any good sales at first glance on bags I like on ILoveDooney, Dillards, or Ebay. $300 is a "big" purchase for me. Sad, but I'm in grad. school. I'm looking for a bag that will last a while and not look too dated.. I'm in my 20s.
I'm debating between 4 bags:
- Dooney & Bourke Florentine Vachetta Small Satchel in Plum
This one is my favorite, as I think it's the prettiest. I like the plum.
This wouldn't fit my iPad very well, and I wonder if this bag just seems too small for daily use. I also wonder if the fold over top part gets irritating to have to keep folding over every time. I prefer the look with the folded top... I don't care for the look with the top part unzipped and straight up.
Comes with nothing.
- Dooney & Bourke Leather Hobo with Logo Lock in Plum
I like the plum, but would that the leather in plum might look a little cheap? The only logo I see it on is on the logo lock. I wonder... does it look "nice" all over? Could it just as easily look like a Target/Walmart back without the logo? Does the logo lock strap get irritating to fasten each time you open the bag? Also, some reviews say the handle strap is short. I have big arms/shoulders and prefer shoulder bags.
I like the coin purse that it comes with... I could use it as a wallet.
- Dooney & Bourke Leather Medium Pocket Satchel in Grape
I really like this one. It was my first choice, but then I wondered... does it look "old/dated/vintage" with the strap? As in, 1990s style or older lady style? It's a pretty bag, I just wonder if it's older and too sophisticated. I'm in my 20s...
The pockets on this bag look the best out of all the bags. The front pocket would be perfect for a phone, and it has an inside pocket for an iPad. Definitely prefer the organization stuff on this one.
I love that it comes with a wristlet and key fob. I don't have a nice wallet/wristlet.
It just looks a bit... dated. Maybe it just reminds me of my relatives 1990s Dooneys. It does look nice... but is it for me?
- Dooney & Bourke Leather Satchel in either Red or Lavender
My 4th choice was a red Dooney & Bourke Leather Satchel. My favorite colors are pink and purple. But, the red sure does look nice on this bag. It's pretty and more modern. The size looks like it would fit enough. Some reviews say it's really heavy and has hard zippers. Some reviews said the shoulder strap rivets break fairly easily.
It comes with a cosmetic case. I might use it as a wallet. I like "free" accessories that come with bags.
I like...
- smooshy, soft leather
- something that can hold: iPad, medium wallet, medium cosmetic case
- not obscenely heavy
- no logo-printed canvas
- mahogany, plum, pinks, maybe red
I have a Coach metallic convertible shopper now. Love it. The leather is so soft and it's held up well for the year I've had it. I'm getting tired of the metallic color... it's kind of a dark bronze color. Coach calls it "gunmetal."
I'm debating between 4 bags:
- Dooney & Bourke Florentine Vachetta Small Satchel in Plum
This one is my favorite, as I think it's the prettiest. I like the plum.
This wouldn't fit my iPad very well, and I wonder if this bag just seems too small for daily use. I also wonder if the fold over top part gets irritating to have to keep folding over every time. I prefer the look with the folded top... I don't care for the look with the top part unzipped and straight up.
Comes with nothing.
- Dooney & Bourke Leather Hobo with Logo Lock in Plum
I like the plum, but would that the leather in plum might look a little cheap? The only logo I see it on is on the logo lock. I wonder... does it look "nice" all over? Could it just as easily look like a Target/Walmart back without the logo? Does the logo lock strap get irritating to fasten each time you open the bag? Also, some reviews say the handle strap is short. I have big arms/shoulders and prefer shoulder bags.
I like the coin purse that it comes with... I could use it as a wallet.
- Dooney & Bourke Leather Medium Pocket Satchel in Grape
I really like this one. It was my first choice, but then I wondered... does it look "old/dated/vintage" with the strap? As in, 1990s style or older lady style? It's a pretty bag, I just wonder if it's older and too sophisticated. I'm in my 20s...
The pockets on this bag look the best out of all the bags. The front pocket would be perfect for a phone, and it has an inside pocket for an iPad. Definitely prefer the organization stuff on this one.
I love that it comes with a wristlet and key fob. I don't have a nice wallet/wristlet.
It just looks a bit... dated. Maybe it just reminds me of my relatives 1990s Dooneys. It does look nice... but is it for me?
- Dooney & Bourke Leather Satchel in either Red or Lavender
My 4th choice was a red Dooney & Bourke Leather Satchel. My favorite colors are pink and purple. But, the red sure does look nice on this bag. It's pretty and more modern. The size looks like it would fit enough. Some reviews say it's really heavy and has hard zippers. Some reviews said the shoulder strap rivets break fairly easily.
It comes with a cosmetic case. I might use it as a wallet. I like "free" accessories that come with bags.
I like...
- smooshy, soft leather
- something that can hold: iPad, medium wallet, medium cosmetic case
- not obscenely heavy
- no logo-printed canvas
- mahogany, plum, pinks, maybe red
I have a Coach metallic convertible shopper now. Love it. The leather is so soft and it's held up well for the year I've had it. I'm getting tired of the metallic color... it's kind of a dark bronze color. Coach calls it "gunmetal."
Last edited: