First Antigona. Black or pearl grey???

hermesholic

LovesOrangeBoxes
Jan 19, 2014
182
88
TheOrangeSide
Dear givenchy tpfers, help me decide on my first givenchy in small Antigona! I feel that the grey matches my wardrobe better but the black is more stunning. Wat do u guys think?? TIA!! 😘 ImageUploadedByPurseForum1408357222.918805.jpg ImageUploadedByPurseForum1408357237.039256.jpg
 

bluedahlia

O.G.
Dec 11, 2005
139
14
New York City
Both are great choices, for a first antigona; I would go with the black. The shiny black antigona is very beautiful and classic.... But get what you will get the most out of and love!
 

ninarella

Member
Jan 31, 2014
20
0
Germany
Both are absolutely beautiful! but i think you should get the grey, it is more special like the black one.
I love the silver grey combination, its bright and shiny.
You can buy the black antigona in another season. Just my Point of view ; )
 

hermesholic

LovesOrangeBoxes
Jan 19, 2014
182
88
TheOrangeSide
Wow, both are beautiful! I think the black one packs more punch. If either will work, base your decision on which you REALLY love.


Both are great choices, for a first antigona; I would go with the black. The shiny black antigona is very beautiful and classic.... But get what you will get the most out of and love!


Both are absolutely beautiful! but i think you should get the grey, it is more special like the black one.
I love the silver grey combination, its bright and shiny.
You can buy the black antigona in another season. Just my Point of view ; )

Thank you, ladies! I agree that the black one is more stunning but the grey is more "uncommon". LOL

Any more votes??
 

pinksky777

Member
Jun 11, 2013
1,058
958
montreal,qc
Definitely black! Does it have to be the shiny lord leather though? I find the goatskin more luxurious looking especially in black IMO.
 

PurseACold

Louboutin, 2010s Givenchy, & 2020s Bottega Veneta
Jan 7, 2014
1,312
76
New York, NY
Thank you, ladies! I agree that the black one is more stunning but the grey is more "uncommon". LOL

Any more votes??
I read this earlier today but couldn't find a way to answer because both are so nice, so you won't go wrong. I think there are 2 ways to answer your question: (1) which one couldn't you live without?, and (2) do you have a need for a basic black bag? Maybe if not, go with the beautiful pearl grey. If so, get the black.
 

GivenchyLuc

Member
Apr 16, 2013
559
2
Both are beautiful and neutrals...how do you choose? I would assess my current collection and buy the one that would be the best addition.
 

hermesholic

LovesOrangeBoxes
Jan 19, 2014
182
88
TheOrangeSide
I read this earlier today but couldn't find a way to answer because both are so nice, so you won't go wrong. I think there are 2 ways to answer your question: (1) which one couldn't you live without?, and (2) do you have a need for a basic black bag? Maybe if not, go with the beautiful pearl grey. If so, get the black.


Both are beautiful and neutrals...how do you choose? I would assess my current collection and buy the one that would be the best addition.


I love the grey!

It's a difficult but happy dilemma isn't it, ladies?? Thanks for your opinions!! Decisions decisions...
 

rougris

Member
Aug 8, 2014
16
0
I agree that the black has more oomph and is the epitome colour for Antigona, but the grey is beautiful! The grey definitely looks better in your IRL picture than in the stock pictures in several online retailers, I can see that the grey is actually not pale at all. Would you say that the grey is somewhat a chameleon (with a tint of blue) or is it pure grey?
 

hermesholic

LovesOrangeBoxes
Jan 19, 2014
182
88
TheOrangeSide
Black! I bought my nightingale in brown so later I can have an antigona in black. Black antigona is stunning!!

Wow u've got it all planned out! Nice!!

I agree that the black has more oomph and is the epitome colour for Antigona, but the grey is beautiful! The grey definitely looks better in your IRL picture than in the stock pictures in several online retailers, I can see that the grey is actually not pale at all. Would you say that the grey is somewhat a chameleon (with a tint of blue) or is it pure grey?

Yes yes! I've never been a black bag person and this is the first time I feel that a bag looks good in black! Hmmm.. So far for the times I've tried or see the grey irl, it's a true true grey. Very aptly described by its name, Pearl Grey.