Filling the hole in my collection


Meet Poppy the Pug
Sep 18, 2009
So girls, looking at my collection it's "getting there". I've bought and sold and returned and bought (true to the thread lifecycle of a coachie lol).

I currently have

Patent Jade Hailey (I returned the black one due to the zipper sticking)
Camel Patent Audrey
Khaki Large spotlight
Peyton inlaid C tote
Silver Madison Hippie

The biggest "hole" in my collection is just a basic black bag. I tried to fill this void and purchased black leather audrey. I don't think that I want to buy her again I kind of feel like it wasn't meant to be if that makes sense?? I am also leaning towards something in black signature or op art. All of my bags are either leather, patent or shiny (spotlight), and I really want the bag to be casual.

So I'm pondering these bags..

Black siggie maggie
Black siggie Peyton
Black op art kristin hobo

So? Which one should I get? The size of all of these is pretty comparable I think. I would have to ebay purchase Maggie, and the peyton and kristin are about the same price.
I "think" that i'm leaning towards the peyton. What do you girls think?
Aug 26, 2009
My vote is for black siggy Maggie! I've always admired the Maggie, for the amount of pockets. Having enough space for all your stuff to be organized is a wonderful thing, especially for an every day bag!


Mar 16, 2008
The idea of kristin hobo in leather sounds nice. It would be classy and casual. I haven't seen a picture in the op art version just the leather though.

Good luck, I recently realized I didn't have a plain black bag as well, and it took me a while to figure out what I wanted, but I bit the bullet and got on of the last large leather sabrinas from JAX. I'm really glad I did!