funny you say that. Maybelline Touch of Spice if a fave of mine and I like Mehr. But I think Twig is too grey or blah on me.Twig and Mehr are awesome colors. I am NC 35 for reference and have seen the colors work well across skin tones. Also Maybelline Touch of Spice is a dupe of Twig so you may try it.
I emailed NYX. They replied that it could be an issue of where or when it was manufactured. It's definitely different.my fave everyday lippie was NYX Matte in Natural....I just repurchased and they change it. Used to be a subtle mauvey pink. Now it's a brighter pink. why?