I have sensitive eyes (in addition to having a minor case of dry eye syndrome), and I prefer to wear waterproof mascara because 1) I live in a place that rains a lot and 2) I have short, stubby Asian lashes and waterproof mascaras are the only ones that will hold the curl. Anyway, I'm having trouble finding a good OIL-FREE, opthamologist-tested, eye makeup remover that will get rid of waterproof mascara. I use a few different waterproof mascaras like L'oreal's voluminous and I don't have issues with cleaning that off. But I also use Cover Girl's lash blast volume in waterproof and that is some tough staying mascara and does not smudge one bit (while Voluminous does smudge). I recently bought a bottle of Almay's oil-free eye makeup remover and it doesn't take off LashBlast and it also stings my eyes! Ugh. I just recently got in touch with a local Mary Kay consultant because I read that their oil free makeup remover is really good, so I'll see if I can get some samples. But I was wondering if anyone else had any suggestions to look into? I'm definitely willing to pay a little more for something that works and is gentle on my eyes.