ITA! I don't have the Astrid, but love that style as well!I have the Epi Electric zippy coin purse in black and I LOVE it, I really like the shine! I have the Astrid wallet in black epi electric as well and LOVE that too! I would go for the Zippy wallet, or the Astrid, it's really a gorgeous wallet. I don't have the Sobe clutch but I do like it...however if you think you'll get more use from a wallet I'd go for that! Good luck with your decision!