Edie 31 vs Charlie Bucket

[rosevelours]

I need your opinion please...I have an Edie 31 and I love it, its great working and very confortable for me. Now I am not sure if I should get another Edie 31 in black or Charlie Bucket in black. Is Charlie Bucket as confortable as Edie in terms of shoulder strap and reaching in while carrying it over the shoulder?

I appreciate sharing your experience very much!

 

[holiday123]

I tried the bucket on yesterday and if using the top handle to carry then you would have to pull down to your elbow to get into because the drop isn't too long. If using the longer strap and carrying on the shoulder it's pretty easy to get into. Can even leave the turnlock on the backside undone for easier access to essentials and put wallet etc in front with turnlock closed for more security.

 

[Lee22]

Just grabbed the bucket bag off FOS today. Have several Edie 31’s and love them. Will let you know how I make out once it arrives. Figured I would give it a shot for 60% off

 

[Lee22]

Just grabbed the bucket bag off FOS today. Have several Edie 31’s and love them. Will let you know how I make out once it arrives. Figured I would give it a shot for 60% off

Charlie bucket arrived today and it actually feels very comfortable as a shoulder bag.It is not as bulky as the Edie. I would say it actually feels more natural resting against my body. I am now a fan of both now. Obviously won’t wear until next year but had to try out