Does anyone have two identical, but in different sizes?

Do you or have you had two of the same bag, different size/leather/shade?

  • Same leather/hardware/color, but different size

  • Same size/hardware/color, but different leather

  • Same leather/hardware/size, but different shade of same color

  • No, I try to keep a "spread" between bags, and avoid redundancy.


Results are only viewable after voting.

jedimaster

O.G.
Dec 21, 2006
1,857
66
Do any of you have (or have had) two bags which are the same style, leather, color, and hardware, but different sizes? If so, what bags are (were) they? Do (did) you use both? If you ended up parting with one, was it because you stopped using the less favorite size, or did you just feel like a jerk having this sort of redundancy?

Related question - same question, identical bag/color/size, but different leathers (eg, togo and box; or togo and clemence - please don't laugh, I am just curious) or, close but not identical colors (eg, ebene and chocolate; black and graphite; etoupe and gris torterelle)

I am not in this situation yet, but its not entirely a hypothetical question, due to a bag or two on my wish list.
 

pursemember

Member
May 17, 2006
4,724
17
yes ah and yes and well yes :upsidedown: totally identical different sized less so (i prefer if i need the same style in a different size and same hrdw to have a different leather) but same colorfamily different leather or hardware yes often (i need at least silver AND gold hardware for every and each colorgroup. i try to split them also with styles like red family birkin pall. hrwr and red family bolide gold hrdw but that is not a rule
 

amamxr

Member
Aug 21, 2006
5,294
36
I think I may be guilty :sweatdrop::biggrin: all the same size and leathers but different colors
 
Jun 21, 2006
3,219
9
Do any of you have (or have had) two bags which are the same style, leather, color, and hardware, but different sizes? If so, what bags are (were) they? Do (did) you use both? If you ended up parting with one, was it because you stopped using the less favorite size, or did you just feel like a jerk having this sort of redundancy?

Related question - same question, identical bag/color/size, but different leathers (eg, togo and box; or togo and clemence - please don't laugh, I am just curious) or, close but not identical colors (eg, ebene and chocolate; black and graphite; etoupe and gris torterelle)

I am not in this situation yet, but its not entirely a hypothetical question, due to a bag or two on my wish list.
Hi

I must be a loon! Yes I've had same combination 3 different sizes and also same size and combination with the only variant being h/ware. So I'm having a cull at the moment of near duplicates and an overhaul of my collection. That said black calf box and gold seems to rear it's head in every corner!

BW

Fleurs.
 

S'Mom

Resistance is Futile
O.G.
Apr 8, 2006
19,284
386
LMAO!!!!! I am SO guilty of this!

Same size, same leather but different colors. Same leather, same color but different styles. LOL!!!! I love my black and I love my Box calf........

But I'm trying for variation....I think I'm getting there.
 

lee217

O.G.
Oct 3, 2007
306
7
Would I? U betcha! If I found it......

:heart:1. Blk box Kelly in 28 and 32, right next to each other in the closet. No problemo.

:girlsigh:2. Rouge H in box and chamonix too........I'll take one w/white stitching and PHW, and the other w/matching stitching and GHW.

:love:3. Black togo in both Kelly and Birkin......

the best would be to find them 1 at a time, over a few years........so it's not feast or famine.....but no telephoning....just stopping by while out strolling.....and finding them.....
 

gracekelly

The Red Queen
Authenticator
O.G.
Feb 4, 2006
30,609
32,905
How about same color and same leather same size (ok, 1cm difference)different style? Did that with vermillion chevre in two bags.
 

lee217

O.G.
Oct 3, 2007
306
7
How about same color and same leather same size (ok, 1cm difference)different style? Did that with vermillion chevre in two bags.
Sure....why not......IMHO ESPECIALLY w/different styles....bcause if u luv a skin and color,u want it near u allot, but different style bags do different things...it makes perfect sense to me.....:yes:
 

gracekelly

The Red Queen
Authenticator
O.G.
Feb 4, 2006
30,609
32,905
Sure....why not......IMHO ESPECIALLY w/different styles....bcause if u luv a skin and color,u want it near u allot, but different style bags do different things...it makes perfect sense to me.....:yes:
Thank you for supporting my thought process. However, I must add that I was doubting myself the other day. I thought I had goofed and then talked myself out of it by reminding myself that one is a Drag bag and under the radar and one is a Kelly which certainly is not. Unfortunately I find myself many times having to be in situations where under the radar is preferable. There is a lot of envy out in the world.:crybaby:
 

gracekelly

The Red Queen
Authenticator
O.G.
Feb 4, 2006
30,609
32,905
^Lee, Went back again and looked at your post on your bags. We are both in trouble:P
 

Julide

Ahh Money Penny...
O.G.
Aug 23, 2007
18,595
10,957
Would I? U betcha! If I found it......

:heart:1. Blk box Kelly in 28 and 32, right next to each other in the closet. No problemo.

:girlsigh:2. Rouge H in box and chamonix too........I'll take one w/white stitching and PHW, and the other w/matching stitching and GHW.

:love:3. Black togo in both Kelly and Birkin......

the best would be to find them 1 at a time, over a few years........so it's not feast or famine.....but no telephoning....just stopping by while out strolling.....and finding them.....
:lol::lol::lol::lol:
Works for me!
 

CynthiaNYC

Member
Mar 2, 2007
4,652
20
Would I? U betcha! If I found it......

:heart:1. Blk box Kelly in 28 and 32, right next to each other in the closet. No problemo.

:girlsigh:2. Rouge H in box and chamonix too........I'll take one w/white stitching and PHW, and the other w/matching stitching and GHW.

:love:3. Black togo in both Kelly and Birkin......

the best would be to find them 1 at a time, over a few years........so it's not feast or famine.....but no telephoning....just stopping by while out strolling.....and finding them.....
SO funny because that whole post is almost exactly word for word my answer!

To me, there's never enough black in the world, for one thing. And I totally agree that Rouge H Box and Rouge H Chamonix have different characters and there's a time and place for each of them--best case scenario the time would be now and the place would be in my hand. LOL

The only thing on that list I would personally skip would be a black togo Kelly but that's just me because Kellys have limited use in my current lifestyle and the two sizes in Box would suit my needs perfectly. However, I could totally see having two black Birkins of the same size, different leathers. I would LOVE to have a black Box Birkin to go with my black Evergrain Birkin. :heart:
 

Grill

O.G.
Jan 11, 2007
222
22
Paris
I don't suppose I'm alone or particularly odd in that I have 2 30cm birkins both in Togo both with PHW - one black the other blue jean. They feel and look very different to me because of the colour. I am thinking about adding to my small collection. But this time it'll be something different- hopefully a 35cm birkin in clemence, a 32 cm Kelly in Togo or a 34cm clemence Lindy! ( You know, really I need all three but all in good time!) No more 30cms for me for the mo (etoupe is calling though! and I can totally see the appeal of getting a black 35cm birkin with GHW!)
 

fromparis

O.G.
May 29, 2006
4,872
212
OK, I just own one (Black Box Birkin)...
but the next will be a lot different (Unblack Clemence Massaï)
 

lee217

O.G.
Oct 3, 2007
306
7
SO funny because that whole post is almost exactly word for word my answer!

To me, there's never enough black in the world, for one thing. And I totally agree that Rouge H Box and Rouge H Chamonix have different characters and there's a time and place for each of them--best case scenario the time would be now and the place would be in my hand. LOL

The only thing on that list I would personally skip would be a black togo Kelly but that's just me because Kellys have limited use in my current lifestyle and the two sizes in Box would suit my needs perfectly. However, I could totally see having two black Birkins of the same size, different leathers. I would LOVE to have a black Box Birkin to go with my black Evergrain Birkin. :heart:


^^^I have a teenage daughter:angel::hysteric::supacool::drool::angel:.....I need a default bag......^^^^