I have the Lindsay in Esspresso and Peyton in Black patent. I dont have any pics to compare, will take some after the super bowl and post. The Peyton is almost double in height IMO and width it is slightly wider. The handles on the peyton are alot more comfortable IMO. THe Peytone is alot lighter.
Like baglady mentions, Lindsay is 'squatty' and Peyton is taller.
I find the handles equally comfortable on both bags, but Peyton has the Legacy stripe lining, Bonus! And Peyton is/was available in more colors & fabrications. I prefer my Peytons(5) over my Lindsay(1).