I like and have both. Soft leather (like AGL) is the most comfortable for me, and really it holds up pretty well, most of my shoes from them actually have patent toe caps so that probably helps with wear and tear. I have quite a few patent shoes too (other brands), stiletto pumps, wedges, flats, patent you can wipe clean which is nice but it is stiffer. I have a patent Ferragamo Vara bow short block heel pump as well as a patent Stuart Weiztman platform higher pump, and both of those are pretty comfortable and I can wear all day or for like walking around a mall, but they are not like wearing AGL's. Weekdays when I'm working, I wear AGL probably 3-4 days per week (I don't think about how my shoes/feet are feeling at all on those days) and then like 1-2 days I will wear a different pair of shoes that isn't as comfortable but I want to be different/fashionable. I can't do shoes that aren't very comfortable everyday though.