I just bought the Panarea in the old version 3 weeks ago at the Dior Boutique in Vegas. They had the new version as well but I liked the older one for several reasons & all personal preferences anyways:
1- like the silver charm over the rubber
2- chose the smaller size, whereas the new version only has one size and is quiet large for me
3- the old one is quilted and puffy, the new one is flat
However the old version does wrinkle at the bottom corners a little bit whereas the new one doesn't. It's not something that bothers me though.
Overall I'm very happy with it & I do find it versatile & easy to wear. I do wear it over the shoulder & I find it comfortable. I don't feel like I have to be overly cautious while wearing it, easy to take care of. In fact the first week I was sitting at a table in a restaurant and someone spilt their beer on one side of the bag and some even dripped inside...normally this would've been a disaster but you couldn't even tell that this ever happened. It also has these little silver "legs" at the bottom so when you put it on the ground the bottom is not touching which I like.
I'm just learning about the panarea for the first time and I'm loving the old style for the reasons you just listed (the silver charms, the puffier quilting).
I have a few questions if you don't mind.
What sizes and colors were the old style available in? And was the price of the old style the same as the new?
We don't have a dior near me so I would have to order sight unseen if I get one. Thanks for the info!