They seem extremely similar (if not the same) to all the latest hybrid lipgloss/lipstick products (Maybelline color elixirs, Rimmel Apocalips/Show off laquer, YSL rouge pur couture, L'Oreal Paris Colour Riche Caresse Wet Shine Stain). Subsequently I'm pretty sure I won't be purchasing them since there are so many drugstore dupes already available.
I tried the l'oreal ones and they are very pretty, but they come off very ugly from my lips during the day. I wonder if the other drugstore ones are better, or maybe I chose a bad color of the L'Oreal ones (i have 2 bright colors)?! I got the YSL and I love it, it come off nicely leaving a tint of color.