interesting question, schmoo
i am a perfect example of a Chanel lover who thought she would never buy a classic flap
what changed my mind, and now i think its essential for a Chanel lover to have at least one classic flap in her collection (unless she really doeesnt like them lol), were the following:
1. This Forum
2. The sheer classiness and timelessness and Chanelishness of the bag
3.. The fact that me, being more trendy than classic, needed a totally classic bag: to me, the classic flap is even more classic than the medallion tote and the GST (both of which i have also)
4. The fact that I wanted one white bag in my collection but i didnt want it to be a white everyday bag, and my white caviar classic fit the bill completely (not big enough or "safe" enough -- being white -- for my lifestyle to be an every day "throw around" bag, but perfect for say 2-3 times a week or evenings with our casual lifestyle even at night.
now i love the classic flap, but will most likely not buy another one....