elmel - I know what you mean about the longchamp! I received one as a gift, and I'm surprised at how often that's my bag of choice.
photoobsessive - I got hooked through
Coach actually
I own a couple of their smaller accessories and a few of their bags now, so I wanted to move on to other brands. (ho-boy).
Ooooh all those UK-based bags! Argh, you guys are killing me.
nodoubtdaisy & passerby: WOW. Thanks for the comprehensive suggestions!
For the record, I've browsed my TJ Maxx & Marshall's and realized that I love a lot of Michael Kors' stuff. Some of the Fossil leather is TDF too.
I ultimately fell in love with Ellen Tracy's buttery leather, though, and managed to score a hobo on ebay for a great price. I haven't received it yet but I just wanted to thank everyone for their help! I wouldn't have found out about Ellen Tracy if it weren't for you guys.
I know everyone looks down on Juicy Couture, but after I felt the leather in person....wow. I ended up splurging on a plainer looking tote (so it's not as..."frivolous" as some of Juicy's other stuff). If I'm shunned for liking gorgeous leather, so be it!
Thanks again for your suggestions, everyone