So I went in today to return the Logan in Moss that I was not in love with... and look at the cute keychain I picked up, the Bailey Heart. This is the brushed silver which really is a nice muted metallic.
Love the keychain! They have some supercute lightning-bolt shaped ones as well...
I think the store is more sexy chic than dark + uninviting, it has a quintessential New York feel to it with muted colors, and a modern sexy boudoir vibe... It also seems darker from the street I think because the two neighboring stores happen to be super bright.