I think it depends on where you go, and where you plan on using the bag. In general, a caviar flap will always look more elegant than the cotton club pochette. I also think the caviar flap (Classic or East West) is prettier too. I may be a bit biased though, because I have both of those. But the cotton club would be a good casual bar/clubs, sporting events, or concert bag where you won't mind if people are bumping into it. It's also not structured, so you can wedge it next to you in the seat, etc.