First I wanted the cookie lily, didn't work out. Then I was thinking about the sbs but ended up missing the oak. Just when I thought I had given up on getting anything from this line, I found out my friends friend ended up buying both the black and oak wallet and she wants to sell one of them, doesn't care which, my choice ! Once again, I cant decide as black is so classic and i dont have a black wallet (odd). also don't have to worry about it getting dirty or color transfer as it will end up being held / tossed around a lot..seems like it might age better? The oak is pretty and I think the cutout details stands out more in the oak. And the delicate design matches the lighter color and wondering if the black looks a little harsh. Adding to my dilemma, she will sell either to me at the price she bought them.. The black was 40% off. The oak was 20% off. Not sure if i love the oak $100+ more than the black at this point.... meaning after my other purchases this season. Opinions please! Thanks!