I am not sure, since I don't have any Coach bags yet. But, since I am thinking of getting the Coach Legacy Leather Satchel, I may tie it onto that one. Also, I was wondering, which scarf would be better to tie around the Legacy Satchel, the normal scarf that is pictured above or the ponytail version that you mentioned? Sorry, I am still new to the scarf typing thing, but I saw it on a couple people's bags and I love the look! Thanks so much!Which bag are you thinking of tying it onto?