Okay, I have been debating this and wanting this bag for a long time! I have decided to treat myself to a ocahc legacy mandy shoulder bag since I have sold a few items on eBay. I am just struggling with which color to get. I can't decide between the black leather or natural leather. I have the Ali bag in both natural and black (and whiskey too:shame. I am absolutely love my natural ali but what I don't love are the water spots. But how I love that color...so would you recommend the blk leather or natural leather? Which do you own and for those of you who own several - which is your favorite? Thanks!!