I'm torn! :s I bought the Gigi in Clay. I exchanged it for another Gigi in Clay because I was unhappy with the first one I got (scratches, etc). I haven't use the new one or removed the tags yet because I can't decide whether I should keep it or exchange it for the Gigi in Whiskey. Here's the thing: I like the Clay color a lot and I know that the Legacy leather is supposed to look worn (I have other Legacy collection bags), but I fear that the Clay will look way too beaten up way too fast. Also, I want to use the bag as my everyday work bag and I worry that the Clay color (with all of its scratches and scuffs) will not look professional enough as I work in a relatively conservative field. I know the Whiskey color gets scratched up too, but I think it might not look as bad. Also, out of all the Coach bags I own (and I have MANY), I don't have any Whiskey bags. Then, I look at the Coach website and I notice that the Gigi doesn't come in Clay anymore (it's apparently that popular). I just don't know what to do? Anyone have any thoughts or suggestions?