Classic Evening Clutch: Quilted Nappa or Pebbled Leather?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hi friends,

I am looking to buy a black leather clutch that I can use for after work or evening events. I am struggling between two: the Coach Hayden clutch in pebbled leather, and the Coach Tammie in black nappa quilted leather. Which way should I go?

Before seeing Coach's new quilted leather bags this season I initially had my eyes set on the Hayden because I love Coach's pebbled leather for my everyday work bags (Coach Charlie etc). The quilted leather that's out this season though--I've been caught by surprise with how much I like it in the moment. Pebbled leather is pretty timeless but its also very understated. Is the quilted leather trend a "flash in the pan" situation or will it be as in fashion four or five years from now as it is now? I want something cute but also something that I can still wear in five years without looking out of fashion. Should I go with the pebbled leather or the quilted nappa? See the photos of each below! The first one is the quilted nappa Tammie, the second is the pebbled leather Hayden.

Tammie.png
Hayden.png
 
Top