I don't know, I was trying to work out if I like it, or not, when I saw it in the show...
Think I prefer the half moon one, but I would really prefer if it were soft and slouchy and didn't have the handles (so, a different bag, really!).
I prefer casual, cleaner lines and don't want unnecessary weight in a larger bag.
Also, if a bag is soft and slouchy, you can just gather it up by the (soft) shoulder strap; so, you don't need handles, anyway.
ETA: Just occurred to me that you would probably be scrabbling on the leather/suede, all the time, to pick up those handles (if you ever used them), leaving scratches/marks...
Might be better to just use the strap, anyway.