Charcoal or Black Cherry?

i waitlisted for a black cherry city and ended up changing to a charcoal city when it came it...
the black cherry i ordered was more reddish-brown than a true black cherry...
it's hard if you can't see it in person and pick out one in a tone you like...
the charcoal was gorgeous IRL and the color seemed to be even on all the bags...
 
Many of us are small - I, too, am Hobbit-sized!
Do look at the First and Twiggy sizes too for they aren't too large.

As for your City, it really depends on what your wardrobe is like and if you like to match or not. I bought a staple black First - also because I didn't have a black bag! - and then started adding on depending on what called out to me and also how it'd match my wardrobe.

Charcoal is a nice variation on the classic staple black, but BC (if you get a good one) can also be a classic in it's own way!

Hope this helps and good luck on deciding which to get!
 
Thank you everyone for your replies and opinions..I was more towards the charcoal too. I can see myself using it more often =)

I guess I wll stick to just the city since I bought the sapphire in GSH.

Thank you once again..