Looks to be the same color to me, but if it were me and I loved the color, (I've seen many photos on Instagram) I would choose caviar. To have both available in same shade at same time is very rare for Chanel!Thanks a lot Dear for clarifying it. Is it the exact same tan shade? The cruise one looks tanner in pic or perhaps just the lightning. If it's that tan as in pic, ooww trouble for my wallet.