mommy4luke, I kept the leather ones (#2) and they are Comfy enough. They are very high though. and it's a bit challenging to walk with but i get lots of compliments with them. Since I had both pair for 24 hours in my possession, I noticed the Linens were a bit more difficult to walk with because I felt the Linens did not support my feet enough, and also because of that, it seems like all the weight was in the heels versus the leather ones. Hope this helps. BUT like I said above, for me, the plastic brooch was a no no versus the price. I don't know where you live, but I know these clogs were sold 820 Euros all over Europe, so it really bothered me that with the exchange rate and the price tag - almost double $ 1795 in the US (it was just too much for poor quality). Usually the prices are slightly higher in the US but not that much.