Gosh, I love them both…. I have a 2.55 225 reissue in black with gold hardware and a vintage small classic flap in black lambskin with the gold. So, a few months ago, I bought the black medium classic caviar flap with silver hardware to round out my collection and have a silver option.
I must say, that I love that silver on black more than I thought I ever would - and even more each time I use it. The silver is so bright and white. Sometimes, I look at it and think, “Wow! What a stunner!” (Although, I confess I also think that when I glance at those two black/golds — it’s Chanel, after all!!!).
Generally speaking, I reach for the gold hardware for most dressier occasions. But, I find the silver is more versatile - it can easily go from casual to dressy and can be equally as stunning and elegant as the gold IMHO.
Have fun shopping and deciding!