Cartier PG 10 diamond Love or Tiffany YG lock half pave?

Cartier love v Tiffany lock

  • 10 diamond love

    Votes: 18 62.1%

  • Lock half pave

    Votes: 11 37.9%
  • Total voters
    29

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

MainlyBailey

MainlyBailey

O.G.
Feb 4, 2009
2,941
4,770
#1
the first photo is my daily stack. I have split it up into two- one with just the three loves and the other with the rest (and a Bulgari serpenti WG bracelet).

I had ordered the Tiffany lock but it was defective so I have a chance to either get a new one or forget that and get another love but with 10 diamonds in PG. I’m attaching a photo with the lock included. I wouldn’t wear it like that as I don’t wear all of them at the same time or on the same wrist. Thanks for your thoughts!

1420BD82-C469-4897-B48F-3EEDE44C0DE7.jpeg

73AF0EDF-953D-4053-A4BD-AF29C577F583.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: scheurin
#2
Personally I am not a fan of all of the screwheads on the Love bracelet getting filled in with diamonds, I feel that it looks the original design and meaning of the love bracelet itself.
I also prefer a little variety, and seeing that you already have some Love bracelets, I like how the look changes up a bit with the lock and break up the space a bit. (even though I know you wouldn't wear all of this at once, I prefer the 2nd photo over the 1st one)

Is there one you love more than the other? Is there a reason why you can't really decide between the two?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MainlyBailey
#4
lill_canele said:
Personally I am not a fan of all of the screwheads on the Love bracelet getting filled in with diamonds, I feel that it looks the original design and meaning of the love bracelet itself.
I also prefer a little variety, and seeing that you already have some Love bracelets, I like how the look changes up a bit with the lock and break up the space a bit. (even though I know you wouldn't wear all of this at once, I prefer the 2nd photo over the 1st one)

Is there one you love more than the other? Is there a reason why you can't really decide between the two?
Click to expand...
I had the same thought we not having all the screws covered in diamond- hence why I got the 4 diamond one (the other two non-diamonds are from ages ago). I like variety which is why I ordered the lock but I think I’m having trouble with how it’s not that flush with the rest of my bracelets. Much to ponder over. I also prefer PG from cartier over Tiffany. Tiffany’s PG is soooo pink.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lill_canele
#5
I'm not personally enamored of the Tiffany piece, but you have so many Love bracelets that I'm not sure if you might be gilding the lily a little bit there ... would you consider anything else?
 
  • Like
Reactions: OCMomof3
#7
lovecartier said:
I'm not personally enamored of the Tiffany piece, but you have so many Love bracelets that I'm not sure if you might be gilding the lily a little bit there ... would you consider anything else?
Click to expand...
I’m actually thinking I might retire the current loves- I’ve had them for decades and I feel like I’ve somewhat outgrown them. I’m starting to like the look of diamonds more so I’m definitely open to consider other bracelets. Maybe this Bulgari serpenti? I have the white gold Infiniti one with diamonds.

B827BB2F-6D9C-453F-A59B-34BFF25FA62B.jpeg
 
#9
Swanky said:
Agreed with above post about having plenty of Lives already so I voted Tiffany since those were our only 2 choices.
The Serpenti is on my list!
Click to expand...
Thanks Swanky! Always appreciate your input. I should’ve included the Blvgari as an option- really wasn’t thinking too much of it but it’s growing on me!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swanky
#10
MainlyBailey said:
I had ordered the Tiffany lock but it was defective so I have a chance to either get a new one or forget that and get another love but with 10 diamonds in PG.
Click to expand...

So was the gap with the diamond that you mentioned in the Tiffany Lock thread considered a defect, or there was another issue with it?
My vote goes to the 10 Diamonds Love. While yes, the iconic screw motifs are mostly gone, you still have the 2 screws on the sides. I am not sure if the Serpenti will stack well with Cartier pieces - if I recall the shape is more circular compared to the oval shape of the Love bracelets, but it's also a beautiful design, especially the Demi Pave or Full Pave.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MainlyBailey
#11
xilej said:
So was the gap with the diamond that mentioned in the Tiffany Lock thread considered a defect, or there was another issue with it?
My vote goes to the 10 Diamonds Love. While yes, the iconic screw motifs are mostly gone, you still have the 2 screws on the sides. I am not sure if the Serpenti will stack well with Cartier pieces - if I recall the shape is more circular compared to the oval shape of the Love bracelets, but it's also a beautiful design, especially the Demi Pave or Full Pave.
Click to expand...
It was considered not exactly a defect but it was a bit hard to get the swivel to turn into the lock side. Not sure if I’m explaining this clearly enough but they wouldn’t exactly call it a defect. They said they could repair it but considering it came like this, they are going to exchange it.
I do love the lives and I don’t have the 10 diamond- I took a poll a year ago and went with the 4 diamond but now I want that too. Decisions decisions.
 
#12
xilej said:
So was the gap with the diamond that you mentioned in the Tiffany Lock thread considered a defect, or there was another issue with it?
My vote goes to the 10 Diamonds Love. While yes, the iconic screw motifs are mostly gone, you still have the 2 screws on the sides. I am not sure if the Serpenti will stack well with Cartier pieces - if I recall the shape is more circular compared to the oval shape of the Love bracelets, but it's also a beautiful design, especially the Demi Pave or Full Pave.
Click to expand...
I’ve tried the Serpenti full pave and plain stacking with Love and I’d say the full pave stacks so perfect with Love. I can’t comment on the plain as it wasn’t my size. A Love 15 and 16 will sit well with Serpenti small.
I fell in love with the full pave but didn’t pull the trigger (and look at the price now from its recent $$ increase).
 
  • Like
Reactions: xilej and MainlyBailey
#13
Purrsey said:
I’ve tried the Serpenti full pave and plain stacking with Love and I’d say the full pave stacks so perfect with Love. I can’t comment on the plain as it wasn’t my size. A Love 15 and 16 will sit well with Serpenti small.
I fell in love with the full pave but didn’t pull the trigger (and look at the price now from its recent $$ increase).
Click to expand...
That’s good to know re sizing. I wouldn’t get the full pave but not the completely plain one either. I like the one with a few diamonds. Didn’t realize there was a recent $$ increase for bvlgari but I guess that’s not surprising, considering all brands appear to be doing so.
 
#14
I would go with the lock for a change in look. The diamond lock bracelets are gorgeous but out of my price range. I also love the serpenti and if you are looking at those than that would be my #1 choice. They are just so unique and I'm thinking of getting one in the future!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top