it's really personal preference. do you tend to like your bracelets loose with movement? i notice your other bracelet is snug fitting - would it annoy you if the love constantly went over it etc. if you're still thinking about it and haven't unboxed it may be a sign to go smaller but again its personal preference/comfort. there is no right or wrongDefinitely more than 2inches (somehow I noticed some forumers here tend to use this 2-inches reference ). I'd say more than 3, less than 4.
Do you think that's a sign of sizing down?