I love the chocolate sig carly IRL.. it's so cute! Have you felt the camel leather one in person? I thought I really wanted it, but then I went and felt it at the boutique. The leather was kind of stiff and felt plastic-y. It didn't have the soft, supple leather feel of most other high quality bags so I wasn't very impressed.
i voted khaki gold--> imo the signature pattern and gold looks so pretty it'll go with nearly everything, it would look awesome with jeans and a cute solid shirt! i think it's almost as versitle as khaki saddle...but prettier!