Capucine Birkin35 VS Rose Jaipur Kelly32

which one would you keep?

  • Capucine B35 in Togo

  • Rose Jaipur K32 in Epsom


Results are only viewable after voting.

babyboss

Member
Aug 21, 2010
84
1
vancouver
Hi,

i bought my Capucine birkin35 half yrs ago, and my mom gave me a Rose Jaipur kelly 32 in this christmas.
Dose any one think this two colours are too similar?
I feel both of the two bags are belong to orange family.
And if i only can keep one of the two bags, which one would you suggest me to keep?

Thx
 

Keekeee

In my H closet
Apr 29, 2010
2,116
465
J-Town
Too similar IMO.

I have B35 RJ and had to turned down B30 Capucine when i got offered since the color is waay to similar..
I love both color the same, they are both intense colors..
What are the hardware on your Capucine B and RJ Kelly? If i were you, i would keep the one that has Gold Hardware.
I personally think RJ and Capucine look best with GHW..
 

babyboss

Member
Aug 21, 2010
84
1
vancouver
Too similar IMO.

I have B35 RJ and had to turned down B30 Capucine when i got offered since the color is waay to similar..
I love both color the same, they are both intense colors..
What are the hardware on your Capucine B and RJ Kelly? If i were you, i would keep the one that has Gold Hardware.
I personally think RJ and Capucine look best with GHW..
capucine is GHW and RJ K32 is with permabrass Hardware

btw, the K32 is Gold interior with white lining
 

Keekeee

In my H closet
Apr 29, 2010
2,116
465
J-Town
Then my vote goes to Capucine GHW since its should be togo right?
While the K32 RJ is Candy Kelly with Epsom Leather..
Im not a big fan of Epsom.
I vote Togo Capucine GHW :smile:

Edit: the two colors are too similar in capucine togo and RJ clemence though.. If your RJ is in epsom IMO i think the colors are bit different. Perhaps you should keep both.. ;)
 
Last edited:

wenyihsu

O.G.
Sep 17, 2008
341
535
My vote is to keep the Capucine. I LOVE Capucine with ghw. I'm also not a huge fan of Epsom.
 

carlinha

O.G.
Jul 27, 2008
17,927
2,535
yes i do think they are similar as i was trying on a RJ lindy at the store and had my capucine and a customer commented and said she couldn't even tell they were different colors :shocked: i don't think they are identical but definitely in the same color family and i would consider it repetitive unless you are truly obsessed with these colors.

i am biased since i have a capucine togo B35 which i love immensely, so my vote goes towards that :hbeat:
 

forever132

O.G.
Feb 10, 2009
1,398
85
Sydney
I m not too sure if that is very close color, however they serves different purpose! If you love the color, they can both stay!!!!
 

thyme

Member
Jun 17, 2011
11,835
5,626
i am also bias, i have a capucine B35. but i do prefer capucine to RJ, not a fan of the salmony colour of RJ, whilst capucine is more orange/red..
 

kewave

O.G.
Nov 26, 2008
2,982
735
If you were only going to keep 1 bag, I would choose Birkin over Kelly any day. It's so much easier to use.
 
Mar 26, 2009
18,989
23,080
I think they are too similar. They are two different bags though. If you money is not an issue, why not keep both?