I prefer the Bleeker Shopper, because it's what I'm using now, & it has been the perfect bag for me since I purchased it.
I don't like either wallet . . . The 1st one is too big (I don't carry checks), and the 2nd one has a turnkey that would get in my way (& it's also too big).
Still; you'll need to pick the ones that appeal to you . . . that's not a decision for someone else.