I prefer the 3rd one as well. I do get a teenager/teenybopper vibe from all three however. Not sure if this was intentional or not since you're target audience is young. For me rounding 30yo, I would prefer to visit a website that is classic and streamlined in design and not so gimmicky (yours isn't but I'm just using as an example). I would go for a different color scheme though. Yes, this web page pops but not in a mature way the way I would want. Again, let me reiterate, if you're going for the teenage crowd, this is perfect but maybe with a few minor adjustments, you can hit an even broader age range.
Good luck in your endeavors! I have much respect for entrepeneurs!
I love the 1st one.
Such a clean look and easy to find click thru banners.
I hope you have a great success in your business.
Maybe we all can become your customer!
I prefer the 1st and 3rd mostly the 3rd being my favorite color is black but using lighter colors as well with the black would make it more appealing and stand out more...
I like the third one the best. (I'm 31 by the way.)
While I love everything pink and girly, I too feel that it's a little too girly, and seems more like it's for teenagers. I think if the colors were changed, it might suit an older audience better.
Thanks so much, everyone!!!! We are going back to the drawing board, and I will post in a few days with the new design for further feedback! You guys are awesome, and I appreciate your help...........
Anne
I like the first one best But i think the design might be appealing to 10-15 year olds, not grown women. I'm 17 and it isn't that appealing to me. :S. But the design is fun and fresh, I have to admit that.
I like the 1st one best as well. I do agree though that it looks "young" and seems to be targetting teenagers slighlty. Hope you don't mind me asking but why did u decide to use cartoons?
I like the first one. It does look young but it's also fun and girly. I'm 18 and it appeals to me because it gives me a feeling of nostalgia. It makes me think of the Polly Pocket dolls and Barbies that I played with when I was young. It does look like it might be too young looking for 30 year old though, but I can see it appealing to those from 18-23.