Brown Red Flap - Which to Keep?

[Maebe]

Hi - need your advice! Are these two colors too similar to justify keeping both? I’ve always had the red on the right and recently bought the one on the left because I thought it was more brown, but it does seem to throw red. I’m not sure if they are too similar. Advice / opinions appreciated!

 

[Swanky]

It is a sienna color to me, I'd only keep the true red and add a true brown.

 

[fashion16]

^^^ this

 

[snibor]

Too similar. Agree it looks sienna like. Almost has a more orange tone appearance. I prefer the red one you already have.

 

[stacy_natalie]

Agree, the red on the right is definitely my preference.

 

[Venessa84]

Also agree with the other… I’d pick the one on the right.

 

[Cartier<3]

Another vote for the redder one.

 

[Misha333]

+1 to all of the above, IMO they're too similar and I prefer the red on the right

 

[step2005]

agree with everyone above, no need for the newer one. Is the one one the right 18b? I missed out and always wanted that raspberry red!!

 

[artax]

keep the cherry red!♥️🍒

 

[no5]

I would keep the one on the right although I have a few reds. I think that is 12A if I’m not mistaken. One of favourites along with 17B and 9C 🙈

 

[juju2016]

Hi - need your advice! Are these two colors too similar to justify keeping both? I’ve always had the red on the right and recently bought the one on the left because I thought it was more brown, but it does seem to throw red. I’m not sure if they are too similar. Advice / opinions appreciated!

Too similar but lovely

 

[purselovah91]

they're the sam ebag

 

[chanellover333]

I like the one on the right (unless left matches your current wardrobe better) but agree they are too similar to keep both

 

[gabbyss]

What series is your red on the right? I would definitely keep that one ! It’s lovely ❤️