Hmm...interesting.....you know, i THINK that the Coach website bag measurements are never completely accurate. I've read that here on the forum, I'm pretty sure. Maybe someone else will chime in on this. The one I saw today at Dillard's looked to be the same size as the one I just bought at Macy's.
Lol at you ordering the black one, too! I'm coveting another one as well. I might have to go back and get the plum one!
I have a new hailey, and an old hailey.... this thread elaborates on the differences. If your preference is the "old" - that's what Macy's are (I think they bought out what Coach had left) - and if it hasn't been posted, they are 25% off (and regular price is already 25% less than original retail - ie $228)
New Hailey vs Original Hailey - PurseForum