bobbi brown eyeliner? caviar ink or espresso Ink

[Ms.Qi]

hello everyone,

I'm looking for a dark brown eyeliner gel because black is too harsh on me. anyone has caviar ink and espresso Ink? would love some feed back in which one is more dark brownish? I've looked at some pictures online and the caviar ink seems more grey? i also don't really like the brown to be red brown..i liked some videos where people were using the espresso ink but not sure if it's a red brown. TIA for any input

 

[ncch]

I was looking at eyeliners and checked out Bobbi brown too. I think caviar inks darker than espresso but not as harsh as black. The caviar looked blacker and espresso looked browner. I didn't think it had red undertones. My friend tried the chocolate shimmer (?), I think that leaned a little red.

 

[lolaluvsu]

i have both. the espresso is pretty dark and only when compared with black can you tell it is brown. i do have to say that i use the espresso more.

 

[timelessbeauty]

Espresso is really close to being black so I say go with the caviar ink