I own both Black leather Sophia (brass hw) or Sabrina (silver hw) but they seem like the same style. I am undecided if I should keep them both or not.
Tough call. I say keep Sabrina because you won't get another chance at having one. Sophia can be exchanged for another color. And as much as I say I don't care about the hardware, I DO like black better with silver toned hardware. And it's got three hangtags.
Keep Sabrina exchange Sophia for another color. Sabrina will always be a classic to me.